Essence House

Essence House Not done with faith. Just the container you've outgrown. Ben Shoup. essencehousesd.com

Spiritual direction is the practice of listening for God in your interior life, and discerning how you're being guided toward wholeness.

Joel sat in the parking garage after the best quarter his team had ever had, engine off, hands still on the wheel.His te...
05/12/2026

Joel sat in the parking garage after the best quarter his team had ever had, engine off, hands still on the wheel.

His team was thrilled.

His family put together a congratulatory dinner.

He smiled the whole way through, but something felt off.

He told me, weeks later: "I have everything I worked for. I don't know what's wrong with me; I feel dull."

I noticed the way he said it. Not with despair. With something quieter. Like a question he had been carrying a long time and hadn't known who to ask.

We sat with it.

Then I said: "What if nothing is wrong with you? What if your body is trying to tell you the truth?"

He looked up. "About what?"

"About what you actually need now. Not what you earned. What you need."

He was quiet for a long time. Then, slowly: "I don't think I've ever asked myself that."

When your desires don’t count for anything, life gets siphoned out of you in a way sleep alone can’t restore.

It isn't a malfunction.

It is a message.

Has there been a season where your body was telling you something your calendar had no room to hear?

If you’re in that space, I'd welcome a conversation. PM me to have a free conversation.

Live and Lead with Soul,
Ben

Your body knows you are somewhere you have outgrown before your mind is willing to say it.For years, I stayed in places ...
05/07/2026

Your body knows you are somewhere you have outgrown before your mind is willing to say it.

For years, I stayed in places that had stopped holding me.

I wasn’t aware of the pressure I felt about disappointing people. From having built my identity inside a particular structure. That who I had become was so stitched into a specific set of relationships and rhythms that pulling the thread felt dangerous.

So I stayed. And I watched my pastoral life slowly shift from something I moved toward to something I weathered.

What I did not know then: the restlessness I kept explaining away was not weakness, selfishness, or ingratitude. It was my interior life trying to give me medicine I desperately needed.

Honesty.

There is a particular difficulty in recognizing the unconscious motivation for staying somewhere that is no longer serving you. Because the motivation often looks like loyalty. Like faithfulness. Like not being the kind of person who gives up.

It is worth asking: am I staying because this is where I belong, or because leaving would require me to become someone I have not yet given myself permission to become?

What has it been like to remain in a place that keeps you too small?

Live and Lead with Soul,
Ben

Miriam called it a vice grip.She couldn't stay where she was, and she couldn't imagine who she would be if she left.This...
05/06/2026

Miriam called it a vice grip.

She couldn't stay where she was, and she couldn't imagine who she would be if she left.

This week's post is about that specific kind of stuck: feeling caught between your integrity and your sense of belonging inside a spiritual community. About what the tension is actually asking of you. And about one practice that has helped people move from caught to clear.

Link in the first comment.

Live and Lead with Soul,
Ben

There is a hollow that settles in when you have given everything to a community that can no longer give anything back.Ma...
05/05/2026

There is a hollow that settles in when you have given everything to a community that can no longer give anything back.

Marcus had been a church leader for twelve years.

Hospital visits. Committee meetings. Late-night texts from people in crisis.

One Sunday after service, sitting alone in the emptied sanctuary, a woman from his small group texted: "You're so steady. How do you do it?"

He set his phone face-down on the pew.

He didn't know. He couldn't remember ever thinking he was allowed not to be.

When he came to work with me, he said: "When I sit in that building now, I feel nothing. Like I'm the last one to know something has died."

We sat with that for a long time.

Then I wondered: "What part of you has been asking you to let it pass away?"

He didn’t answer at first, but eventually, he smiled and said, “The part who is always steady, all the time, for everyone else.”

The work of caring for other people's interior lives is real and good.

But it does not replace the work of tending our own and finding balance.

And somewhere in the architecture of most faith communities, our own interior cultivation gets quietly left off the list.

Has there been a season when the place meant to hold your soul became one more place you had to perform for others?

If that’s you, I'd welcome a conversation. PM me for a free call. No obligations for moving forward, just to see if spiritual direction would be a helpful practice for you.

Live and Lead with Soul,
Ben

It’s that terrible, unraveling feeling under your sternum…It keeps grabbing for your attention.I sat with a woman named ...
04/30/2026

It’s that terrible, unraveling feeling under your sternum…

It keeps grabbing for your attention.

I sat with a woman named Rachel last spring.

She had been a faith leader for nearly two decades.

The kind who stayed after every service to pray with whoever needed it, who pushed to show up for every event. She was all in.

She came in and set a folded piece of paper on the table.

"I’m scared I don't believe it the way I used to," she said. "But I don't know what to believe instead. And I'm terrified that if I start pulling threads, my whole life will unravel."

I wondered out loud with her: "What could happen if you welcomed the unraveling, that can’t happen now?"

She looked up.

Something in her face changed.

Not every thread that comes loose harms you.

Sometimes what falls away was never meant to hold your faith forever. It was the certainty that got wrapped around faith so tight you couldn't tell them apart.

Mature faith and inherited certainty are not the same thing.

One deepens with honest questioning.

The other only survives by closing its eyes.

Has there been a moment when the faith that shaped you started asking you to look away from something you couldn't stop seeing?

If that question has weight for you today, feel free to PM me for a free exploratory call.

Live and Lead with Soul,
Ben

"That part of me didn't go to work." She was talking about her grief after her mother died. But once she said it, she re...
04/29/2026

"That part of me didn't go to work." She was talking about her grief after her mother died.

But once she said it, she realized she meant her curiosity too, her faith, her tenderness, her uncertainty. Most of it had been sitting in the car for years.

This week's post is about that gap, what causes it in high-performing leaders, and a two-question practice that takes two minutes and surfaces what you have been leaving behind.

Link in the first comment.

Live and Lead with Soul,
Ben

What if the image of God that runs your interior life is not one you chose? What if it was handed to you, and it’s still...
04/28/2026

What if the image of God that runs your interior life is not one you chose? What if it was handed to you, and it’s still giving all the orders?

I asked a leader recently what he believed God thought of his success.

He went still for a long time.

Then: "Suspicious of it."

That one sentence expressed an enormous truth about his interior life.

The image of God we carry shapes everything. How we hold authority. What we believe about whether our work is ever enough. Whether the hunger we feel for something more real is permitted or self-indulgent. Whether we are allowed to take up the space we actually occupy in the world.

Most of us were handed an image that made functional sense for the people who gave it to us. A God of clear expectations and firm accountability, for instance, is useful for an 8-year-old. It is suffocating when the 8-year-old hits 45 and has been living inside that insufficient image without examination for decades.

Spiritual maturity is not about accumulating answers. It is learning to welcome the death of an insufficient image, so that an image of God capacious enough to hold your actual experience can rise.

Try this: Ask yourself what the God you actually operate from, not the one you're supposed to endorse theologically, but the one running things internally, believes about your work, attitude, or value. Write what comes. One sentence.

Then ask: Is this image capable of freeing me, cultivating joy in and through my life, or evoking gratitude in me?

That gap, if there is one, is where the real work begins.

What do you notice when you examine the image of God that has actually been shaping your interior life?

I'd be glad to continue this conversation. Feel free to PM me to set up a time.

Live and Lead with Soul,
Ben

You’ve started to cringe before you even step foot into that room.Marcus had led his organization for eleven years.He wa...
04/23/2026

You’ve started to cringe before you even step foot into that room.

Marcus had led his organization for eleven years.
He was good at it.

He walked into rooms and delivered messages with a steadiness people trusted.
Clear. Confident. Certain.

In our session, he said something quietly, almost to himself:

"I don't know if I actually believe it anymore.
But I say it better now than I ever did."

He paused.

"When I get home, I feel like I've been in a play."

I asked what it cost him.

He looked away for a moment.
"My sense of self."

This is what nobody says about leadership fatigue.

It's not always about doing too much.

Sometimes it's the specific exhaustion of performing certainty you've outgrown.
Of speaking words that used to feel true.
Of the gap between what you say and what your body knows.

The soul keeps track of what the mouth is saying.
The emptiness and fatigue are interior signals, waiting for someone willing to hear them.

Has there been a moment when you said something you've said a hundred times, and noticed you were performing rather than meaning it?

If you’d like to talk about your experience, I'd welcome a conversation. PM me to set up a free call.

Live and Lead with Soul,
Ben

She stopped talking about the decision and started looking at my face.And I realized she was not looking for my reaction...
04/22/2026

She stopped talking about the decision and started looking at my face.

And I realized she was not looking for my reaction. She was looking for permission to trust what she already knew.

This week I wrote about what happens when you have spent years routing your interior signals through someone else's authority before you act on them, and what it looks like to find your way back.

If that landed somewhere, the link is in the first comment.

Live and Lead with Soul,
Ben

Knowing the official answer is not the same as knowing your own conscience.Most of the traditions that formed us were ve...
04/21/2026

Knowing the official answer is not the same as knowing your own conscience.

Most of the traditions that formed us were very good at giving us answers.

They had lists of what was true, what was permitted, and what was required.
And for a while, those lists felt like a floor beneath our feet.

But at some point, many of us began to notice something.

The list had an answer for everything.
But the answer and our conscience had started to diverge.

Not on the small things.
On the things that mattered most.

Many of us have been trained to feel like spiritual maturity requires us to hold onto those old beliefs with everything we’ve got; to resist change.
In reality, spiritual maturity invites us to develop the truth that we sense within, discern its value, and bring that value into the world.

That process is uncomfortable.
It often requires a period of genuine not-knowing.

It requires letting go of the security of being right in order to discover what you actually believe.

The tradition that formed you gave you a starting place.
Your conscience is inviting you somewhere further.

When did you first notice the gap between what you were taught was true and what your own conscience was saying?

Live and Lead with Soul,
Ben

Address

Northfield, MN
55057

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Essence House posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category