23/06/2026
"Saying back surgery doesn't work is like saying antibiotics don't work for a cough."
That's how Prof Aaron Buckland, Australian spine surgeon trained at NYU Langone Health in New York, explains one of the most misunderstood topics in modern medicine.
Antibiotics absolutely work for pneumonia. They don't work for a virus. Spine surgery is the same. For the right patient with the right diagnosis, the results can be excellent. For the wrong patient, surgery makes the pain worse.
The problem is, almost nobody is having that conversation honestly.
In this week's episode of The Pain Diaries Podcast, Aaron sits down with Dr Nick Christelis for one of the most candid conversations on spine surgery we've ever recorded.
We cover:
When spine surgery is the right answer - and the patients who clearly aren't candidates. Why ACDF treats arm pain more reliably than neck pain. How cervical disc replacement compares to fusion. Adjacent segment disease and the long-term risks patients are rarely told about. Why "failed back surgery" is the wrong term — and what persistent spinal pain syndrome actually means. What to do if you've already had surgery and you're still in pain.
Aaron also explains why he's never told a patient they need surgery — and the published research on the 6-month decompression window that's changing how the best surgeons think about timing.
With over 180 peer-reviewed publications and a public commitment to publishing his own surgical outcomes, Aaron is one of the most credentialled and most transparent spine surgeons working in Australia today.
If you're considering spine surgery, or you've had it and the pain hasn't gone, this is worth your time.
Full episode on YouTube: https://youtu.be/Aa0Zlxtz_mg
if you've had spine surgery and you're still in pain, that's exactly who we see at Pain Specialists Australia. A Melbourne specialist pain medicine practice with clinics in Richmond, Heidelberg, and Bayside. A normal scan does not mean the pain isn't real. It means the diagnosis needs to go deeper. Every person's situation is different, which is why proper assessment matters.
Book an assessment: https://painspecialistsaustralia.com.au/contact
For educational purposes only. Not medical advice. Individual results vary. Decisions about spine surgery should only be made following formal assessment by a qualified specialist.