06/08/2026
Tice et al. (2025) surveyed 1,460 United Methodist clergy and interviewed 49 pastors to ask: what actually stresses clergy out, and does it look different depending on their mental health?
Three big buckets emerged — professional conflict (92% cite conflict with supervisors), family strain (73%), and ministry-specific pressures like political polarization (65%, jumping to 93% among the most distressed clergy).
These stressors show up across every mental health profile — including clergy who are thriving. Flourishing isn't the absence of stress. In the presence of stress, it is also whether clergy have the resources, meaning, purpose, and support to carry it.
Full Citation
Tice, L., Salgado, G., Johnston, E., Nascimento, B., Lee Bo-Hyeong, J., Proeschold-Bell, R. J., & Eagle, D. (2025). The weight of the yoke: a qualitative analysis of the stressors for clergy across a mental health continuum. Mental Health, Religion & Culture, 28(2), 111-127. https://doi.org/10.1080/13674676.2025.2536533