08/25/2026
Shame is sometimes used in parenting as a way to correct behaviour: “What is wrong with you?” “You should know better.” “You’re so selfish.” “You’re embarrassing me.” While these words may stop a behaviour in the moment, they can leave a much deeper and longer-lasting impact.
Shame is different from accountability and it is also different from guilt.
Guilt says, “I did something wrong.” Shame says, “There is something wrong with me.”
Guilt can actually be healthy. It helps children recognize when their actions have hurt someone, take responsibility, make amends, and choose differently next time. Guilt focuses on behaviour and encourages repair.
Shame focuses on identity. Instead of helping a child think, “I made a poor choice,” shame can lead them to believe, “I am bad,” “I am disappointing,” “I am not good enough,” or “I am unworthy of love.”
That distinction matters.
Healthy guilt can build empathy and responsibility. Shame can damage self-worth.
When children are repeatedly criticized, humiliated, compared to others, mocked, threatened with embarrassment, or made to feel that love and approval depend on their behaviour, they can begin to internalize those messages. Instead of learning, “I made a mistake,” they may come to believe, “I am a mistake.”
Over time, shame-based parenting can contribute to low self-esteem, anxiety, perfectionism, people-pleasing, secrecy, difficulty admitting mistakes, emotional shutdown, anger, and an intense fear of disappointing others. Some children become exceptionally compliant, not because they have developed healthy self-discipline, but because they are afraid of rejection, criticism, or humiliation.
Shame can also damage the parent-child relationship. Children who expect judgment may become less likely to tell their parents when they are struggling, have made a mistake, are being bullied, are experimenting with risky behaviour, or simply need help. Emotional safety is built when children know they can tell the truth and still remain worthy of love and connection.
Healthy parenting does not mean allowing harmful behaviour or avoiding consequences. Children need boundaries, correction, responsibility, and guidance. The difference is correcting the behaviour without attacking the child’s identity.
Instead of “You’re so lazy,” try, “Your responsibilities haven’t been completed. Let’s figure out what needs to happen.”
Instead of “Why do you always ruin everything?” try, “That choice caused a problem. How can we repair it?”
Instead of “You should be ashamed of yourself,” try, “What happened wasn’t okay. Let’s talk about who was affected and what you can do to make it right.”
This allows a child to experience appropriate guilt, recognizing that their behaviour caused harm, without turning that feeling into shame about who they are.
Children learn best when accountability and connection exist together. They need to understand that actions have consequences while also knowing that mistakes do not make them unworthy, bad, or unlovable.
One of the most powerful messages a parent can communicate is:
“I will hold you accountable for what you do, but I will never make you ashamed of who you are.”
If you’re having difficulty parenting a tween or teen, let’s connect for a session. 705-929-3970