08/06/2026
You Don't Belong Here. You Don't Belong There Either. And That's Not a Failure.
A reflection for those who chose Barcelona — and lost the map home in the process.
________________________________________
There is a particular kind of loneliness that doesn't have a proper name in English.
People from Galicia call it Morriña — the ache for distant places. But this isn't that. This isn't the longing to leave. This is what happens after you've already left. After the apartment is decorated, the SIM card is local, the café order comes out in Catalan. After you've done everything right.
And still, at dinner parties, someone asks: "So, where are you from?"
And you pause a half-second too long.
________________________________________
The Myth of the Rootless Freedom
The cultural narrative around expat life is intoxicating: freedom, reinvention, a life curated across continents. Barcelona makes it especially easy to believe. The light is generous. The pace has mercy. The city seems to whisper that you can be whoever you want here.
But Carl Rogers — one of the founding voices of humanistic psychology — argued that human beings have a core need he called congruence: the alignment between who we are, where we are, and who the world reflects back to us. When that alignment breaks down, we don't feel free. We feel fragmented.
And fragmentation, over time, is exhausting in ways that are hard to explain to people who haven't felt it.
________________________________________
What Rootlessness Actually Feels Like
It's not dramatic. That's what makes it so disorienting.
It's the way you switch languages mid-sentence and lose the thread of your own thought. It's returning "home" for the holidays and realising you've become a slightly foreign version of yourself to the people who knew you first. It's the Facebook memories that feel like dispatches from someone else's life.
It's being genuinely happy here — and genuinely missing something you can't name.
Abraham Maslow, in his later work, spoke of belongingness not as a comfort, but as a biological need — as fundamental as safety. To be unmoored isn't a lifestyle choice. It registers in the nervous system as a low-grade threat. The body doesn't distinguish between a broken community and a broken continent.
This is why "but you live in Barcelona!" is the most well-meaning and least helpful thing people say.
________________________________________
The Identity That Grows Between Borders
Here's what the textbooks don't tell you: the pain of rootlessness isn't a problem to solve. It's a developmental experience.
Psychologist Kenneth Gergen described the modern self as polyphonic — not a single, coherent melody, but many voices in dialogue. Most people develop one dominant cultural voice. Expats develop several. That's not a deficit. It's a richer, stranger instrument.
But — and this is important — only if you stop fighting the dissonance.
The expats who suffer most are those who are waiting: waiting to go back, waiting to fully arrive, waiting to decide. Suspended between two coasts, belonging to neither. What Rogers would call conditional regard turned inward: I will accept myself fully once I know where I am.
That day doesn't come. Not that way.
________________________________________
What Integration Actually Looks Like
Rollo May wrote that freedom is not the absence of commitment, but the ability to choose one's commitment and live by it.
Integration, for a person between worlds, is not about finding a single place to belong. It's about building a portable identity — one that doesn't depend on geography to feel legitimate.
It starts with a few honest questions:
What values did I bring with me that I want to keep? Not the habits, not the food preferences — the actual values. The ones that survived the crossing.
What have I grown here that I didn't have before? The tolerance for ambiguity. The capacity to start over. The eye that sees a culture from the outside and the inside simultaneously.
Who sees me fully — not just the local version of me? Because that person, or those few people, are your real home. Not a city. Not a passport.
________________________________________
A Note to Those in the Hard Middle
If you are in the phase where the novelty has worn off and the roots haven't grown yet — you are not failing at expat life. You are living it honestly.
The research on this is consistent: the psychological adjustment curve for long-term expats typically bottoms out between 18 months and 3 years. It is the least Instagram-able phase. It is also, often, the most transformative.
What helps is not pretending the disconnection isn't real. What helps is naming it, without catastrophising it. You are not broken. You are in transition. There is a difference.
And if Barcelona has taught us anything, it's that the most interesting things happen in the space between categories — between Spanish and Catalan, between Gothic and Modernista, between the mountain and the sea.
You might be one of those things.
________________________________________
The Question Worth Sitting With
Not "Where do I belong?"
But: "Who am I, regardless of where I am?"
That's not a simple question and that's one of humanistic psychology’s central questions asked to anyone honest enough to stay with the discomfort long enough to hear an answer.
Barcelona will wait. The question won't.
________________________________________
If this resonated, share it with someone who's navigating the beautiful, disorienting reality of building a life between worlds. And if you're in the hard middle right now — feel free to reach out. Sometimes naming the thing is the beginning.
________________________________________
