12/11/2026
When did disagreement become a competition rather than a contribution?
We’re familiar with debates presented as opposing sides.
For or against. Right or wrong. Winners and losers.
But I wonder whether we’re allowing a similar approach to shape conversations in our organisations.
Because when the objective becomes defending a position rather than examining an issue, something valuable can be lost.
What are we seeing?
~A leader presents a proposal.
~Someone offers a different perspective.
~The discussion quickly becomes about whose approach is right, rather than what might be learnt.
What’s happening underneath?
When disagreement feels personal, people can become more invested in defending their position than examining the evidence.
Others may decide it’s safer not to contribute at all.
And suddenly, critical thinking gives way to protecting positions.
Why does it matter?
Because organisations need more than confident opinions.
They need sound judgement, alternative perspectives and the willingness to question assumptions.
Without those things, commercial decisions can go insufficiently tested, valuable contributions can be lost, and customers may ultimately experience the consequences.
What could leaders do differently?
👉Create room for people to question ideas without feeling they’re questioning someone’s authority.
👉Encourage curiosity before conclusions.
👉And demonstrate that changing your mind in response to good evidence isn’t weakness.
Having spent many years in demanding senior leadership environments, I understand the importance of making decisions and getting things done.
But I’ve also learnt that being decisive and being divisive are not the same thing.
Good leadership doesn’t require everyone to agree; It requires the ability to consider different perspectives, make informed decisions and take responsibility for them.
When being right becomes more important than getting it right, everyone stands to lose.