09/03/2026
My explanations, no matter how true they were, were just excuses called by another name.
I Was Wrong, But… - My Explanations
Confess your faults one to another, and pray one for another, that ye may be healed. James 5:16
This weekend I made a mistake while umpiring a tournament. Near the end of the game I got one scoring scenario stuck in my head and reported the final score wrong. I knew the rule. I was tired, I was coasting a little, and in my mind this was a game that really didn’t matter. I just blew it. A coach challenged the score, the tournament director got involved, and it was corrected. The right team advanced. The situation was resolved, but I wasn’t.
When the tournament director asked me what happened and how I had reported the score, I started defending myself. I told them, “I did exactly what you told me to do.” They shot back, “No, that was an if scenario. That wasn’t the case here.” They were right. I was wrong.
Later I found myself complaining to my partner about it. I said I had been so focused on the tie scenario that even after one team pulled ahead, I still had the tie rule stuck in my head. I said it was only a consolation game anyway. What difference did it make? If it was that important, maybe the tournament director should have been there themselves. I kept spinning on something that had already been corrected. Then my partner said, “It’s my fault too. I was there, and I knew the rule too.” Then he added something that stopped me: “I just owned it and told them I screwed up.” I immediately saw what I had been doing. I had admitted I made a mistake, but I hadn’t really owned it. Every explanation I gave my partner was another way of saying, “I was wrong, but…” Even if what I was saying was true, none of it changed the fact that I made the mistake.
As I thought about why I reacted that way, I realized I was embarrassed. I have been umpiring a long time. I know the rules. I don’t make those kinds of mistakes. At least that is what I told myself. Because apparently, I do. Then I saw it. Pride. Instead of just saying I screwed up, I started explaining why I did it and pointing out what everyone else could have done differently. Before recovery, I would have kept telling anyone who would listen what everyone else could have done differently and never even considered what I could have done differently. Instead, the next day I called the tournament director and apologized. I apologized for challenging them, for the way I behaved, and for deflecting responsibility instead of admitting I screwed up.
I am not pleased with how I behaved, but making one mistake does not have to become another mistake. Once I see my part, I can own it without excuses, make amends where necessary, ask God to help me change and show me how to make it right. Then I can let it go. I don’t need to defend myself. I don’t have to explain why I did it. The most honest thing I can do is simply admit, “I was wrong. I screwed up.” Which I did. Although it may not feel or seem like it…that is the gift of recovery for me.
Reflection
When I take responsibility, do I still try to make myself look better by explaining why I did it?