06/10/2026
I recently had a conversation in a session where a client tried to defend their criticism of someone by saying that they always thought critical thinking was a good thing.
But, being critical and using critical thinking are not the same thing, and in some ways they are actually opposites of one another.
Being critical often starts with judgment.
It looks for flaws.
It assumes there is a right answer and a wrong answer.
It can leave us feeling defensive, ashamed, or disconnected.
Critical thinking, on the other hand, starts with curiosity.
It asks:
✨ What am I missing?
✨ What other perspectives exist?
✨ What evidence supports this?
✨ How might someone else experience this differently?
✨ What can I learn here?
Being critical tears down.
Critical thinking explores.
One closes the conversation.
The other opens it.
In relationships, being critical can sound like:
“You always do this wrong.”
Critical thinking sounds like:
“I wonder what’s happening here and how we got stuck in this pattern.”
In our own minds, being critical sounds like:
“I should have known better.”
Critical thinking sounds like:
“What can I learn from this experience?”
Many of us were taught that criticism makes us smarter, stronger, or more prepared. But often, criticism simply makes us more afraid of making mistakes.
Growth doesn’t require constant self-judgment.
It requires reflection, curiosity, and the willingness to consider that there may be more than one truth in the room.
The next time you catch yourself being critical of yourself or someone else ask yourself:
Am I judging, or am I trying to understand?
The answer can change everything.