07/22/2023
I am "never" going to say don't lift weights or do other resistance training. However, anectdotally as a 60+ woman who has done resistance training since the early -mid 1970s as part of competitive swimming programs. I chose universal weight machine classes for school PE because it made me a faster swimmer and fit into my twice/day pool workout schedule the best. My commitment to a weight training and gym schedule ebbed and flowed through my adult years, but I always came back to it.
Now long post-menopausal I have seen clear evidence of muscle loss for quite a few years, but I am convinced that stronger quads, hamstrings, biceps, etc. are not what is most likely to help me avoid frailty as I age. Helpful yes, for sure, but is it balance, stability and proprioception that will help most, in my opinion. Bigger muscles won't make it easier to avoid falls if I have crappy balance, instability in my hips/knees/ankles or have to look down to see where I am placing my foot with each step.
Because I have been a fitness consumer my whole life, and a provider for some of it, I get marketed to A LOT. And I see a lot of marketing around the concepts in this Washington Post article. You know pictures of really old ladies doing various barbell lifts. Great. Nothing wrong with it.
But please, please, please spend at least as much time on balance, stability and proprooception as you do weight/resistance training, because without those, all the muscles you gain lifting are likely, e.g. to be crumpled on the floor at the bottom of the stairs with the rest of you because you missed a step and couldn't get your balance quickly.
Any type and amount of weight training works to build strength and mass, whether people lifted heavy weights or much lighter ones