08/04/2026
Let me guess⌠you found this an odd thing to say?
Thereâs a difference between setting a boundary and trying to âwinâ an interaction.
Lately Iâve seen phrases like âWhat an odd thing to say,â âThatâs an inside thought,â and similar responses being praised as emotionally intelligent. I understand why people are drawn to themâtheyâre concise, they feel empowering, and they shut down inappropriate comments quickly.
But I think we should pause and ask what theyâre actually accomplishing.
Many of these statements donât communicate an impact, a need, or a boundary. Their primary function is to evoke embarrassment. They say, âYou should feel ashamed that you thought or said that.â
As a therapist in training, thatâs something I wrestle with.
Shame can absolutely stop a behavior in the moment. It can also stop vulnerability, honesty, repair, and connection. It often creates defensiveness rather than reflection.
That doesnât mean we should tolerate rude, invasive, or offensive comments. Boundaries are essential. But thereâs a meaningful difference between:
âThat comment doesnât sit well with me.â
âIâm not comfortable discussing that.â
âCan you help me understand what you meant?â
âŚand responding in a way thatâs designed to make someone feel foolish.
Should we be teaching our clients âif they go low, you go lowerâ?
Sometimes a sharp response is warranted. Sometimes youâre prioritizing your own safety or ending a conversation quickly. Context matters!
But if weâre teaching these phrases as the gold standard of emotionally healthy communication, I think weâre missing an opportunity to model something deeper.
As therapists especially, I donât believe our job is to fight shame with shame. I think our work is to communicate clearly, hold firm boundaries, and leave room for accountability without unnecessary humiliation, and show our clients how to do the same.
Curious where others land on this. Do you see these phrases as healthy boundary-setting, or do they sometimes cross into socially acceptable shaming in the form of a âclap backâ?