08/19/2026
Sacramento Superior Court Holds California Massage Therapy Council (CAMTC) in Contempt of Court for Violating Court Order
June 25, 2026 — The Sacramento County Superior Court has found the California Massage Therapy Council (CAMTC) in contempt of court for violating the Court’s Preliminary Injunction requiring CAMTC to process certification applications submitted by graduates of A2ZHealth Massage School.
In its ruling, the Court stated: “The Court finds beyond a reasonable doubt that Defendant is in contempt of court for violating the October 22, 2024 Preliminary Injunction.” The Court applied one of the highest legal standards in the judicial system, concluding beyond a reasonable doubt that CAMTC failed to comply with a lawful court order.
The ruling is a significant development in the ongoing litigation between A2Z Health.Net- massage school, and CAMTC and raises broader questions regarding the accountability of a private nonprofit corporation entrusted with substantial regulatory authority over California’s massage therapy profession.
The litigation followed a sequence of events that A2ZHealth believes evolved into a prolonged campaign of retaliation and what the school describes as a “witch hunt,” with actions against A2Z escalating over time and ultimately resulting in devastating consequences for the school and its graduates. After the Superior Court ordered CAMTC to end its investigation of A2ZHealth and process graduates’ certification applications, CAMTC pursued revocation of A2ZHealth’s school approval and issued its revocation decision on the eve of its contempt trial concerning CAMTC’s noncompliance with that injunction.
During the contempt proceedings, the Court heard testimony from multiple CAMTC employees. The Court concluded that CAMTC applied standards and procedures to A2ZHealth that differed from those applied to other approved schools.
For nearly three decades, A2ZHealth operated as a family-owned California educational institution, educating thousands of massage therapy students. CAMTC's actions have had devastating consequences for A2Z and its community. A2Z has suffered substantial financial and reputational harm, while hundreds of qualified graduates faced prolonged certification delays that prevented them from entering the workforce, earning a livelihood, and pursuing the careers for which they had trained
A2ZHealth has also raised serious governance and transparency concerns. The same organization defending itself in court investigated the school, prosecuted the allegations, conducted the administrative proceedings, and ultimately decided the school’s fate.
For more than three years, A2ZHealth repeatedly asked CAMTC’s Board of Directors to investigate the conduct of its staff, including its CEO, Ahmos Netanel, and Director of Educational Standards Division, Joe Bob Smith, and to independently review the matter. However, the Board did not respond and remained completely silent.
In a related case, ESL massage therapy applicants are represented by pro bono counsel through AJSOCAL in litigation alleging discriminatory treatment by CAMTC, including treatment affecting Asian applicants. A2ZHealth believes these allegations, together with the issues raised in its own litigation, warrant independent and legislative review.
A2ZHealth is calling upon the California Legislature to examine CAMTC’s governance, enforcement practices, transparency, and the adequacy of the current regulatory framework. The Legislature must consider establishing an independent complaint and review process so concerns about CAMTC are not investigated by the same individuals or departments that are the subject of the complaint.
A2ZHealth also believes legislative review should examine the fundamental conflict between California’s student-protection framework and CAMTC’s practices. The Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education (BPPE) promotes educational continuity and measures such as teach-out arrangements to minimize student harm. In contrast, CAMTC refused to permit A2ZHealth to implement a teach-out and declined to recognize education completed after its revocation decision. CAMTC treated the revocation as immediately effective even though A2ZHealth had not yet exercised its right to appeal to CAMTC’s Board of Directors, imposing the consequences before the administrative appeal could occur. When one California regulatory framework seeks to preserve educational continuity while another effectively prevents it before an administrative appeal is heard, the Legislature should examine whether greater due process, and governmental oversight are necessary.
“No private organization exercising this level of authority should be beyond accountability or above the rule of law. We will continue pursuing every lawful avenue available to defend our school, protect our graduates, and advocate for meaningful reform until justice is achieved,” A2ZHealth stated.
About A2ZHealth
A2ZHealth.Net, Inc. Massage School served California students for nearly 28 years and educated thousands of massage therapy professionals. The school continues to advocate for transparency, accountability, due process, and legislative oversight of California’s massage therapy private regulatory system.
Timeline of Key Events
• January 4, 2023 – CAMTC asked A2ZHealth to identify ESL graduates for interviews and hearings.
• September 7, 2023 – Superior Court granted a Preliminary Injunction prohibiting CAMTC from requiring A2ZHealth graduates to undergo education hearings or informal interviews as a condition of certification.
• September 21, 2023 – CAMTC placed A2ZHealth under investigation and ceased processing certification applications submitted by its graduates.
• October 22, 2024 – Superior Court granted a second Preliminary Injunction ordering CAMTC to end its investigation into A2ZHealth and resume processing graduates’ certification applications.
• January 23, 2025 – CAMTC issued a Notice of Proposed Revocation of A2ZHealth’s school approval.
• April 24, 2026 – CAMTC issued its decision revoking A2ZHealth’s school approval.
• April 27, 2026 – Superior Court conducted the three-day civil contempt trial.
• June 25, 2026 – Superior Court found CAMTC in contempt beyond a reasonable doubt for violating the October 22, 2024 Preliminary Injunction.
Supporting Court Documents
October 22, 2024 court Injunction
June 25, 2026 contempt ruling
Additional resources for your review:
AJSOCAL PRESS RELEASE
AMTA Advocacy- State License
Healwell Podcast
California relies heavily on a voluntary, nonprofit certification system administered by CAMTC, while the majority of U.S. states regulate massage therapists through state licensing boards. In California, approximately half of cities and counties recognize or require CAMTC certification, while others do not, creating a fragmented and inconsistent regulatory landscape. There are approximately 50,000 CAMTC-certified massage professionals statewide, alongside an estimated 25,000 individuals working without certification, as well as others who may face barriers to obtaining certification
[email protected]