06/21/2026
All birth carries risk. The problem lies in the lack of informed consent.
"My baby would have died if I had given birth at home."
I hear this often. And sometimes, it's true. But what about the opposite?
There are real emergencies. Situations where rapid surgical or medical intervention saved a baby's life. I am deeply grateful for skilled providers and the hospitals equipped to handle those moments.
But here's a question worth asking: what caused the emergency?
Because the opposite of that statement is also true.
Pitocin leads to an epidural. The epidural leads to fetal distress. Fetal distress leads to an emergency C-section that saves the baby.
Or membranes are ruptured before baby has descended, leading to a cord prolapse and an emergent cesarean that saves a baby who may never have been in danger if the membranes had been left intact until a later stage of labor when baby was low and rupture occurred on its own.
Both of these are real, common stories. And both get told the same way: "You’re so lucky you were in the hospital."
Rarely do we hear the fuller version: that the emergency was set in motion by an earlier intervention, one that may not have been medically necessary in the first place.
No birth, in any setting, is without risk.
At home, we work to minimize that risk by staying low intervention and trusting physiologic birth. By only stepping in when something is truly needed, not because it's routine or convenient. This doesn't eliminate risk. Nothing can. But it does mean we aren't creating emergencies through unnecessary intervention and then resolving them.
This is not a hospital problem or a homebirth problem. It's an informed consent problem.
When a baby is harmed or lost in a hospital, we rarely ask what led there. The system absorbs it quietly. Blame isn’t placed.
When a baby is harmed or lost at home, the mother often carries that story and judgement publicly, for years. Headlines and sensationalism. Blame.
The truth is that both settings carry risk. Both settings save lives.
Sometimes complications are simply complications, unrelated to any prior intervention or choice.
But the narrative usually only goes one direction. We hear about the dangers of homebirth constantly. We rarely hear about what interventions, if any, led to the emergency.
Both stories deserve to be told. You deserve the full picture, not just the version that gets repeated the loudest.