04/02/2026
I get several calls per week from people dealing with cancer, and of course there is still a lot of confusion coming from sources that many think are reliable.
There is a big difference in the effects of egg consumption on developing bodies and adults. They are quite nutritious for the former, but can have serious consequences on the latter.
Very Common Statement:
"I don't know who to trust".
Truth and real evidence is buried so deep by big industries and big government - it is very hard to find.
Here is an investigative Report on Eggs, and Plant vs. Animal Choline in Cancer Risk:
Why Plant Sources Are Superior
1. The Choline-Cancer Connection:
Choline’s role in cancer progression is complex, but emerging research highlights critical differences between animal-derived and plant-derived choline. Animal-based choline (ex. eggs, liver) is metabolized by gut bacteria into trimethylamine (TMA), which the liver converts to trimethylamine N-oxide (TMAO) - a pro-inflammatory compound linked to atherosclerosis, insulin resistance, and accelerated cancer metastasis [S-1][B-9][A-10].
Elevated TMAO levels correlate with poorer outcomes in colorectal, prostate, and breast cancers due to their role in promoting angiogenesis and tumor cell survival [S-2][B-6][A-4].
In contrast, plant-based choline (ex. cruciferous vegetables, legumes) is rich in fiber and polyphenols, which modulate gut microbiota to suppress TMAO production.
For example, feruloylputrescine in citrus peels inhibits the bacterial enzyme cntAB, blocking TMA formation [A-10]. Additionally, plant choline sources like natural soy lecithin and quinoa contain anti-inflammatory flavonoids (ex. quercetin, luteolin) that counteract TMAO’s carcinogenic effects [B-8][A-14].
2. Plant food components that deliver choline alongside cancer-protective cofactors absent in animal products are:
Fiber, which binds excess choline in the colon, reducing its conversion to TMA [B-5][A-15].
Antioxidants, like cruciferous veggies (ex. broccoli, kale) provide sulforaphane and indole-3-carbinol, which detoxify carcinogens and downregulate oncogenes [B-1][A-3].
Phytates, found in legumes and whole ancient grains - phytates (IP6) chelate iron, preventing oxidative DNA damage and inhibiting tumor growth [B-7][S-6].
Clinical data from the EPIC study revealed that high meat consumption (including poultry) correlated with a 3× greater weight gain - a cancer risk factor, compared to plant-based diets, independent of caloric intake [B-9].
Conversely, populations consuming choline from soy, lentils, and nuts exhibit lower TMAO levels and reduced cancer incidence [A-14][B-10].
3. Institutional Bias and Misleading Dietary Guidelines - The FDA’s choline recommendations (550 mg/day for men) disproportionately emphasize animal sources, ignoring evidence that:
Choline deficiency is rare in humans, as the liver synthesizes sufficient amounts when folate and B12 status is adequate [B-1][A-6].
High-dose animal choline (ex. 2+ eggs/week) elevates prostate cancer risk by more than 70%, whereas plant choline shows no such association [B-3][A-11].
Pharmaceutical interests promote choline supplements (often derived from eggs) despite risks, while suppressing research on plant-based alternatives like citicoline (from soy) [A-4][B-8].
4. Practical Recommendations for Cancer Patients
Minimize or replace animal choline with these plant-powered alternatives:
Soy Lecithin: 1 tbsp provides 50 mg choline + genistein (anti-angiogenic) [B-10][A-14].
Quinoa: 1 cup cooked = 43 mg choline + complete protein [A-3][B-5].
Shiitake Mushrooms: Rich in ergothioneine, a mitochondrial-protective antioxidant [A-7][B-4].
Cruciferous Veggies: Steam broccoli to preserve sulforaphane [B-1][A-12].
5. Conclusion: A Paradigm Shift Toward Plant Choline
The carcinogenic potential of animal-derived choline is well-documented, while plant sources offer detoxification, fiber, and anti-cancer phytonutrients.
REFERENCES:
Science Papers:
[S-1] "Reduced Cholinergic Status in Hippocampus Produces Spatial Memory Deficits When Combined With Kainic Acid Induced Seizures" by Unknown (Neurobiology of Aging 29(1):3-14 [2008])
[S-2] "Guinea Pig as an Animal Model for the Study of Urinary Bladder Function in the Normal and Obstructed State" by Jacek L. Mostwin Omer M.A. Karim Gommert Van Koeveringe Narihito Seki (Neurourology and Urodynamics 13: 137-145 (1994))
[S-3] "GMl Ganglioside Protects Nucleus Basalis From Excitotoxin Damage: Reduced Cortical Cholinergic Losses and Animal Mortality" by S.P. Mahadik F. Vilim A. Korenovsky S.E. Karpiak (Journal of Neuroscience Research 20:479-483 (1988))
[S-4] "BRAIN TEMPERATURE AFTER DEATH" by E. Robins D.E. Smith G.E. Daesch K.E. Payne E.G.S. Spokes G.M.J. van Kempen G.F.J.M. Vrensen E.G.S. Spokes (J. Neuroehem.)
[S-5] "Differential Changes From Selected Brain Immunolesion of the Forebrain System in Cholinergic Markers Regions After Specific Rat Cholinergic Basal S." by S. RoRner R. Schliebs J.R. Perez-Polo R.G. Wiley V. Big (Journal of Neuroscience Research 40:31-43 (1995))
[S-6] "Molecular Species of Choline Glycerophospholipids and Ethanolamine Glycerophospholipids in Goat Liver" by Young K. Yeo, Ryun B. Tak, Bernadette C. Celi[] (Food Chemistry 0308-8146/89/$03-50 © 1989 Elsevier Science Publishers Ltd, England. Printed in Great Britain)
[S-7] "Animal Models of Alzheimer's Disease: Glutamatergic Denervation as an Alternative Approach to Cholinergic Denervation" by TROND MYHRER[] (Neurosclence and Biobehavtoral Revtews 17(2) 195-202 1993)
Books:
[B-1] "Therapeutic Use of Medicinal Plants and their Extracts Volume 2 Phytochemistry and Bioactive Compounds ANM Alamgir" (author unknown)
[B-2] "Build Your Running Body A Total-Body Fitness Plan for All Distance Runners From Milers to Ultramarathoners—Run Farther Faster" by Pete Magill
[B-3] "The Vitamin Revolution in Health Care" by Michael Janson
[B-4] "An A Z Guide to Food Additives Never Eat What You Cant" by Deanna M Minich
[B-5] "Contemporary nutrition issues and insights" by Wardlaw Gordon M-3
[B-6] "Beating Cancer with Nutrition Rev 2005" by Patrick Quillin
[B-7] "IP6 Natures Revolutionary Cancer Fighter" by Abulkalam M Shamsuddin
[B-8] "The anti-Alzheimers prescription the science-proven plan to start at any age" by Fortanasce Vincent_1
[B-9] "How Not to Diet" by Michael Greger MD FACLM
[B-10] "The Encyclopedia of Nutrition and Good Health" by Robert Ronzio
Articles:
[A-1] "Folic acid deficiencies are widespread here - NaturalNews.com, December 29, 2005" by NaturalNews.com
[A-2] "Exciting new study uncovers combination of nutrients that can slow down brain aging - NaturalNews.com, December 16, 2024" by NaturalNews.com
[A-3] "Healthy habits for a healthier body_ 13 Reasons to choose nutrient-rich whole foods over processed junk foods - NaturalNews.com, November 08, 2019" by NaturalNews.com
[A-4] "Vit B3 in the Crosshairs Should You Worry - ANH International, March 21, 2024" by ANH International - ANHinternational.org
[A-5] "Berry facts and benefits_ What makes berries so good for your health - NaturalNews.com, August 20, 2020" by NaturalNews.com
[A-6] "Choline_ An essential nutrient for brain and heart health - NaturalNews.com, April 10, 2023" by NaturalNews.com
[A-7] "Prepper pharmacy 17 Medicinal plants you can grow indoors year round - NaturalNews.com, January 08, 2024" by NaturalNews.com
[A-8] "Aloe vera_ a holistic staple throughout history - NaturalNews.com, February 16, 2022" by NaturalNews.com
[A-9] "Four Inexpensive Whole Food Supplements - NaturalNews.com, October 15, 2008" by NaturalNews.com
[A-10] "Study Compound in orange peels can protect against atherosclerosis - NaturalNews.com, July 18, 2024" by NaturalNews.com
[A-11] "Review of Aubrey Organics 100 Percent Natural - NaturalNews.com, September 23, 2008" by NaturalNews.com
[A-12] "Heart disease Causes and cures - NaturalNews.com, January 15, 2013" by NaturalNews.com
[A-13] "Insufficient acetylcholine responsible for those senior moments, here are natural ways to increase its levels - NaturalNews.com, August 20, 2018" by NaturalNews.com
[A-14] "Tofu - sources health benefits nutrients uses and constituents at NaturalPediacom - NaturalNews.com, June 27, 2017" by NaturalNews.com
[A-15] "Keep your gut healthy and clean by avoiding these 4 types of food - NaturalNews.com, August 17, 2020" by NaturalNews.com
Summary: Plant-Based Choline Reduces Cancer Risk While Animal Sources Increase It: Why Experts Recommend Switching.