09/10/2026
The Satanic Panic gets remembered as religious hysteria. It was closer to a clinical failure — driven by therapists, spread by daytime television, and built on suggestive memory work.
🕯️
It began in 1980 with Michelle Remembers, a bestselling and later discredited account of "recovered" satanic cult memories. The psychiatrist who co-wrote it went on to marry the patient. Nothing in it was ever verified.
⚖️
The McMartin nursery case ran from 1983 to 1990 and became the longest and most expensive criminal trial in American history. Children were interviewed with highly leading techniques and produced claims no evidence supported — tunnels under the school, teachers who could fly. Seven years, over $15 million, zero convictions. The panic spread to more than a hundred other nurseries, and in some of those cases workers were jailed on charges later overturned. In 1992, FBI investigator Kenneth Lanning concluded the satanic networks did not exist.
🪞
Why it was possible: memory is reconstructive, not a recording. Loftus & Pickrell showed false events can be implanted in healthy adults. Garven et al. showed McMartin's interviewing style reliably produced false claims from children.
🧠
To be clear: child abuse is real, common, and was historically dismissed. The lesson isn't to disbelieve people. It's that certainty plus suggestion can build a vivid memory of something that never happened. And Otgaar et al. found belief in repressed memory has risen among clinicians since the 1990s, not fallen.
📩
Comment the word newsletter and I'll send the sign-up link. Check your hidden requests inbox so it doesn't get lost.
📚
Loftus & Pickrell (1995), Psychiatric Annals. Garven et al. (1998), Journal of Applied Psychology. Lanning (1992), FBI NCAVC. Otgaar et al. (2021), Perspectives on Psychological Science.
. . . .