06/11/2026
Somewhere along the way, we started confusing being a good parent with keeping our children happy.
A child refuses dinner, so we prepare something else. A teenager spends six hours on their phone, and we're afraid to take it away because they'll be upset. A child speaks disrespectfully, and instead of correcting the behaviour, we convince ourselves they're simply expressing their feelings.
We want our children to love us. We want them to feel heard. We want to give them the freedom and opportunities we may never have enjoyed growing up. But Leonard Sax raises an uncomfortable question in The Collapse of Parenting: What happens when our desire to make children happy prevents us from giving them the guidance they actually need?
Sax, a family physician with a PhD in psychology, argues that many parents have gradually surrendered their authority to their children, their children's friends, and increasingly, the digital world. His concern is that children are being given adult levels of freedom before they've developed the judgment, discipline, and emotional maturity to handle it.
What interested me most was his discussion of how much influence parents have lost to peer culture. A child may care more about what classmates think than what their parents believe. A teenager may take advice about relationships, appearance, and personal values from social media while dismissing conversations at home.
And parents, worried about appearing controlling or old-fashioned, sometimes withdraw from the very responsibilities their children still need them to fulfil. Sax examines these issues through discussions of family relationships, food, education, medication, screens, and children's emotional well-being.
5 lessons I took from the book:
1. Your child needs a parent more than another best friend.
Friendship is built on equality, but parenting involves responsibilities that children cannot yet carry. You can listen to your child's opinions, respect their feelings, and enjoy their company while still establishing rules and making difficult decisions. Sometimes loving your child means disappointing them.
2. Don't let screens become the strongest influence in your child's life.
Sax is particularly concerned about how digital entertainment and peer culture shape children's habits and values. Setting reasonable limits on phones, games, and social media helps create more room for family conversations, physical activity, sleep, and real-world experiences.
3. Small family routines matter more than we realize.
Eating together, having regular conversations, establishing bedtime routines, and spending time without devices may seem ordinary. But these habits create opportunities for parents to offer guidance, strengthen relationships, and stay involved in their children's lives.
4. Teach humility alongside confidence.
Children should know they're loved and valuable, but they also need to understand that the world doesn't revolve around their wishes. Sax emphasizes teaching respect, gratitude, responsibility, and consideration for other people. Confidence matters, but so does learning to accept correction and disappointment.
5. Protect your child's childhood without making life effortless.
Children need room to make mistakes, experience frustration, develop patience, and gradually take responsibility for their choices. We can support them through challenges without removing every obstacle. The goal is to help them become capable adults, rather than making every moment of childhood comfortable.
What stayed with me from The Collapse of Parenting is how easily love can become confused with giving in. A parent can spend money, provide opportunities, buy expensive gifts, and work tirelessly to make a child happy while overlooking the importance of consistent guidance.
I think Leonard Sax is right to remind us that children need adults who are willing to lead, even when their decisions aren't immediately appreciated. But that leadership must come with affection, patience, fairness, and a willingness to listen. Authority without warmth can become fear, just as affection without boundaries can leave children without direction.
For me, the healthiest approach lies in combining both.
Children should grow up knowing that their opinions matter, their feelings deserve respect, and their parents love them deeply. They should also understand that love doesn't mean getting everything they want.
Because raising a child is about preparing someone to live well in a world where things won't always go their way.
BOOK: https://link.amazon/B05zRwEml