11/09/2026
HER KILLER HAD ONCE WORN A BADGE. DNA HELPED EXPOSE HIM.
Remembering Cara Jo Roberts
Harrisonville, Missouri
November 5, 2008
Eighteen years ago today, Cara Jo Roberts was murdered inside her own home. She was 30 years old, a wife and the mother of a little boy named Carter.
Before her name appeared in crime reports, Cara was a Harrisonville High School graduate who had earned a business degree from Central Missouri State University. She worked in insurance and enjoyed shopping, camping, barbecues and time with her family. Her obituary made special mention of how much she enjoyed her son.
On November 5, 2008, her husband returned from work around 5:30 p.m. and found Cara in the bathtub. She had been shot in the head.
Investigators recovered cut zip ties and duct tape. Testing revealed an unidentified male’s DNA. Samples from 61 people failed to produce a match, and the leads began going cold.
In 2011, investigators approached Jeffrey Dean Moreland, a former Grandview police officer.
What followed was a deliberate attempt to mislead them.
According to the appellate court record, Moreland obtained blood and a cheek swab from his daughter’s fiancé. He then pretended to collect his own samples in front of a former colleague and handed over the substituted material.
Investigators uncovered the deception. After his arrest in Iowa, they obtained his DNA through a search warrant.
It matched evidence from Cara’s body. His fingerprint was also identified on the adhesive side of the duct tape.
Moreland was convicted of first degree murder and armed criminal action. He received life without parole, followed by 50 years. His convictions were affirmed on appeal in 2015.
The evidence also connected Moreland to another woman’s murder. In January 2020, he pleaded guilty to second degree murder and armed criminal action in the October 2010 killing of a woman in her south Kansas City home.
But Cara’s story deserves more than the name of the man who killed her.
Her nickname was “Care Bear.” A community event called the Grin & Bear It 5K was established in her memory, raising money to help Cass Regional Medical Center patients with needs such as medication, transportation and medical supplies.
That is part of her legacy, too. A community remembering her by helping others.
Today, we remember Cara’s life, the family who loved her and the years with her son that were taken from them.
Cara Jo Roberts.
Thirty years old.
Loved. Remembered. Not forgotten.