21/10/2026
When did we start defending the absence of compassion?
Over 13,000 people have reacted to my recent post about our experience in Minor Injuries.
I've read hundreds of comments.
Some have shared heartbreaking experiences of feeling dismissed, humiliated or invisible within healthcare.
Others have spoken about the extraordinary kindness they received from NHS staff at their most vulnerable moments.
And many healthcare professionals have shared the immense pressures they face every day.
But there's something in the responses that has genuinely surprised me.
Not the number of people who have experienced a lack of compassion.
Sadly, that didn't surprise me.
What surprised me was the number of healthcare professionals who appeared to believe that a lack of compassion could somehow be justified.
Because the department was busy.
Because staff were exhausted.
Because the NHS is underfunded.
Because other patients were more seriously unwell.
Because perhaps my daughter's injury wasn't serious enough to warrant attending.
And I have found myself asking a question.
When did we begin measuring someone's entitlement to kindness against the severity of their suffering?
Does a child with a minor injury deserve less reassurance than a child with a broken bone?
Does someone who attends unnecessarily deserve to be treated with less dignity?
Does the fact that you've already seen 30 patients mean the 31st deserves less compassion?
Does the patient who arrives at the end of a difficult shift somehow become responsible for everything that happened before them?
Of course not.
And yet, somewhere in these conversations, that seems to be what we are suggesting.
I am a nurse.
I know the pressures. I have worked through them.
I have experienced the exhaustion, the competing demands and the frustration of trying to deliver good care within systems that make it increasingly difficult.
I am not suggesting healthcare professionals should be endlessly patient, endlessly available or immune to the effects of burnout.
But I am suggesting that we must be very careful about what we begin to normalise.
Because when we repeatedly justify a lack of compassion, we risk lowering the very standards that should define our profession.
And the danger is that we stop recognising it as something that needs to change.
We begin to call it understandable.
Then inevitable.
And eventually, acceptable.
I have been reflecting on this through my faith.
Jesus demonstrated compassion in circumstances that were far from comfortable.
He experienced grief, exhaustion, rejection and suffering.
He also withdrew to rest.
He recognised the need for solitude and restoration.
But His compassion was never determined by whether the person in front of Him was sufficiently deserving of it.
He saw people.
Not interruptions.
Not inconveniences.
Not another demand on His time.
People.
And perhaps that's what troubles me most about the responses to my post.
We have become so accustomed to defending the pressures on healthcare professionals that we sometimes forget to defend the dignity of the people they care for.
We can have compassion for an exhausted nurse without dismissing the suffering of a frightened child.
We can understand why a receptionist is overwhelmed without suggesting that someone struggling to stand should be left without assistance.
We can recognise that the NHS is in crisis without allowing that crisis to redefine what constitutes acceptable care.
These truths can coexist.
And I want to be very clear.
This is not about demanding perfection.
People have difficult days. People make mistakes. People sometimes respond in ways they later regret.
I have too.
Compassion does not mean we will always get everything right.
But surely it means that when we don't, we remain willing to recognise it.
To reflect.
To apologise.
To do better.
What concerns me is not that compassion sometimes fails under pressure.
It's that we seem increasingly willing to defend its absence rather than question it.
And that should concern every one of us.
Because the patient standing in front of us today could be our mother tomorrow.
Our father.
Our partner.
Our child.
Or ourselves.
And when that day comes, I doubt any of us will be comforted by being told that the person treating us has had a difficult shift.
We will simply hope to be treated with dignity.
With kindness.
With humanity.
So perhaps the conversation we need to have isn't just about how we fund the NHS.
It's about how we preserve the values that make healthcare care.
How we support healthcare professionals without silencing patients.
How we recognise burnout without excusing harmful behaviour.
And how we stop treating compassion as something that can only be offered when circumstances are favourable.
Because dignity is not a reward for being the sickest person in the waiting room.
And compassion should never be reserved for the easiest patient on the easiest day.
It is the foundation of care.
And it belongs to everyone.